OK, I was able to reproduce this on the MSTW Development Site. (Good catch! Thanks.) The problem will only occur for sites that have (a) upgraded from 1.0 (rather than starting with 1.1), and (b) previous changed the default settings for the league(s) in question. It comes from a weakness in a the current design. Here’s how to fix it in the WP admin:
1. Capture any front-end screens (team schedule tables) you want to preserve. You are going to have to re-configure the settings for the league.
2. Go to the Leagues screen, edit the league(s) in question, and change it’s sport to something you have not used. (On the dev site, I changed the Pac-12 from “NCAA Football” to just “Football”, but it could have been Badminton, it doesn’t matter.
3. Voila! The asterisks will now appear …
4. BUT, you will have to reconfigure the new sport to match the old. That’s where your screen captures will come in handy.
Worked for me, should work for you. Let me know.
-Mark