League and Seasons look okay. I’m working on 4 sites right now. None exhibit the behavior your describing. So something is different with your site.
1. Back to basics: What version of WP? … PHP? … the plugins? … theme and version? Please provide ASAP.
2. Deactivate all other plugins and try again. Anything change? If the problem is fixed, you can then activate the plugins one at a time until one breaks it. That will be the source of the conflict.
3. Have you set up debug? The debug log could also offer hints about 1 and 2.